I haven’t posted in a while, but I’m thinking of reactivating this blog and/or doing a podcast. As a reminder, this blog isn’t just about Christopher Hitchens the man, but about the issues he cared about. The most important being anti-totalitarianism, whether it comes as religion or state oppression. He wrote frequently about freedom and the threats of authoritarianism in notable works including “Why Orwell Matters”, “Jefferson: Author of America”, and “Thomas Paine’s Rights of Man”.
On this blog I wrote a piece in August of 2019, called “Taking on ‘What Would Hitchens Have Thought‘” where I make the case that he would be outraged by Donald Trump and the Republicans and the media and that we can say this with a high degree of certainty. Now things are much worse regarding the threats to our democracy and the semi-authoritarianism under which we are already living. Here is my note, 10 months before the election for friends and family, to convince them not to vote for Trump. I missed some things including the support of the bros and high Latino support, but I think I got the broad strokes right, which is unfortunate for our country. A scorecard follows the text.
Editor’s note: Originally written January 20, 2024. Edited in November 2026 for tone and typos only. The predictions are unchanged.
Predictions for the 2024 Election (January 20, 2024)
Unfortunately, I have a very dim view of the future for America, which I think will have terrible consequences for the world.
Barring unforeseen events (the death of Trump or Biden), I think Trump will win the election, probably by a large margin, even if convicted. My thesis is that the destruction of democracy is profitable, and a number of factors are conspiring to elect him.
On the Republican side
- Perpetuation of the big lie. More and more people believe it as it’s repeated. Republican politicians who are cagey about whether the election was stolen will, one by one, declare that it was, once Trump makes it a litmus test. Trump has successfully poisoned American minds against all institutions but himself. Can a democracy survive without faith in its institutions, in a post-truth environment?
- The Republicans’ lack of nerve. They could have been rid of Trump, but McCarthy revived him because it helped him become Speaker, and the rest fell in line. If they haven’t already, they will. Trump recently alluded to the fact that eventually they all take a knee. If you think the Republicans look weak now, just wait. Their resolve won’t get stronger a second time around. Robert Kagan makes the point in this insightful, troubling opinion piece from the Washington Post.
On the Democratic side
- Democrats look vulnerable on immigration. They acted slowly at the beginning of Biden’s term, and the Republicans have a point here. In NYC we have reduced basic services to pay for the migrants. Of course we should have legal immigration, but we can’t accept everyone who shows up and pay for them forever. It’s not sustainable, nor is it good policy. If even progressive people like me feel this way, imagine how center-right America feels.
- Biden doesn’t project strength and has timid surrogates. Maybe he will fight harder, but he comes across as feeble and doesn’t call out his former colleagues, which he could do effectively. He thinks being a traditional good guy, getting along with the other side and being a gentleman, will win Americans’ respect. That’s bringing a knife to a gun fight. His surrogates are equally meek in defending him.
- Key Democratic constituencies won’t vote. He is losing support among Black and Hispanic voters, and among the young. Many young voters hold him to a standard of perfection on every issue, and they are unhappy with his handling of Israel and Gaza. I worry they will protest by staying home, even if it means getting a president who will fight aggressively against rights for gay and trans people, Muslims, non-Christians, women, the environment, equality and the poor.
General
- Citizen ignorance and little ability or will to determine the truth. I think America is already in decline. Most Americans couldn’t pass a simple citizenship test and understand very little about our form of government and its history. Many take democracy for granted and don’t realize what they’d lose by voting for Trump. Many accept a one-line conspiracy theory on a Facebook meme rather than reading several news sources. Trump and right-wing media have poisoned the population against the media, the FBI/CIA, the justice system and even the military.
- The money will follow Trump. There are many financial incentives against democracy. Wall Street and the investor class vote on tax rates. News media, even the so-called middle or left, are driven by ratings and profit rather than news. They feel obliged to give equal time to both sides on every issue, and they know Trump is good for ratings. Social media companies see a windfall from dividing people and spreading misinformation. Wall Street will make a lot of money on a Trump presidency in the short-to-medium term.
- Fundamentalist Christians are mobilized and embraced by Trump, which is a standard playbook tactic of aspiring dictators. Expect the wall between church and state to crumble. Religious conservatives have already shaped a Supreme Court I consider corrupt.
- Third-party candidates like Kennedy, and possibly Manchin, will likely draw more votes from Democrats and independents.
Bottom line forecast
- Many things can thwart Trump, but I still think it’s more likely than not that he is elected. If so, he will further erode democracy. He will signal to the world and to industry that he’s open for business, trading policy for cash. He will gut regulation, erode the environment, discriminate against blue states, use the government to target perceived enemies, erase the line between church and state, lower taxes for the rich and cut services for the middle class and poor. He will pardon himself and the January 6 defendants. Being an elected official will become more profitable, and fewer good people will run. In the long term the erosion of democracy will hurt the economy, but in the short term the markets will rally and the rich will get much richer. People will be popping champagne about the stock market while they lose rights daily. More astute players will understand what they’re losing and decide that, if it’s all going to hell, the best they can do is protect themselves and their families by gaining wealth. Expect oligarchs loyal to Trump to gain power and massive wealth, Putin-style.
- The international scene will further erode. Dictators will be emboldened while America’s allies are abandoned. Trump will pull out of NATO and Putin will finish off Ukraine and probably, with no opposition, take over other countries. For all its faults, a leading and powerful American democracy keeps a lot of bad actors in check to some degree. The great American experiment will have come to an end.
Risks to the thesis
- Trump is convicted. This may dampen some support, but so far none of the allegations have moved the needle. I don’t think the January 6 case will be settled before the election, but even if it is and he’s convicted, I think he’ll still win. I’ve been hoping for a factor that could doom him, but I don’t see one. The worse his behavior, the more people support him. They think he’s tough and strong.
- Deaths or dramatic declines in health. Trump’s death would matter. If Biden dies, that might strengthen Trump’s case, since Kamala Harris is not popular and has already been “Hillary-ized” by the right. Both men show their age. Are the examples we see cherry-picked, or do they indicate a trend? If either gets dramatically worse before November, it helps the other.
- An improving economy. This is perhaps the best hope for re-electing Biden. Many signs point to a better economy and stock market. It looks like we pulled off a soft landing, and consumer confidence and other metrics are improving. The markets are optimistic, and with AI there are strong parallels to the 1990s internet bull market. Perceived inflation is still a problem, though. Even as it declines, the public sees it as a problem, which isn’t helped by food and consumer companies keeping prices high to capture margin.
- A black swan event. An example would be a meaningful attack on the US, here or abroad. It could help Biden, since the public tends to rally around the incumbent, but if it’s poorly handled (or the right’s misinformation is effective), Trump can present himself as the only one tough enough to lead.
The scorecard: what I got right and wrong
Written in November 2026, looking back at the January 2024 forecast above.
| Call | What happened |
|---|---|
| Trump wins | Right. He won in November 2024. |
| “Probably by a large margin” | Partly. He won the Electoral College decisively, but the popular vote was close. |
| Wins even if convicted | Right. He was convicted in New York in May 2024 and won anyway. |
| Jan 6 case not settled before the election | Right. |
| Biden projects weakness | Right, with a twist. After the June 2024 debate he withdrew, and Harris became the nominee and lost. |
| Black and Hispanic support slips | Right, and I underestimated it. Latino support for Trump rose sharply. |
| Third parties hurt Democrats (Kennedy, Manchin) | Mostly wrong. Kennedy dropped out and endorsed Trump. Manchin didn’t run. |
| Republicans fall in line | Right. |
| Pardons for January 6 defendants | Right. |
| Self-pardon | Moot. The federal cases were dropped after the election, so he never needed one. |
| Short-term market rally | Largely right at first. |
| Trump pulls out of NATO | Not so far. He has repeatedly threatened to and has pulled back troops, but the US is still a member. |
| Putin finishes off Ukraine | Not so far. The war continues, though US support has been cut back. |
